Bastrop, Tx–The city council listened intently Tuesday while architect Mervin Fatter reviewed plans for a new city hall and convention center on Chestnut St. Then some council members unloaded unflattering criticism on the building designs, suggesting they are too harsh, stark and unrepresentative of the city’s historical building fabric and character.
Fatter defended his preliminary designs, saying in their present stage they are chiefly meant to suggest the “massing” of the new structures which will virtually face each other on either side of Chestnut Street/Loop 150 between the Union Pacific railroad line and Gills Branch. The architect said the current plan calls for using materials such as native sandstone, brick and stucco and features including “porches” at the civic center to reflect the town’s historic building materials and architectural features.
Fatter also noted that the city’s Main Street Design Committee–which is also the Historic Landmark Commission–noted that the area along Chestnut St. has a history of industrial buildings since the 19th century, including the former MKT Railroad train depot. Council members, led by Mayor Terry Orr, said the convention center and city hall designs need more work to suggest and reflect Bastrop’s architectural heritage. Orr suggested that the city hall design, especially, needs more softening, perhaps with “porches” or other friendly-to-people features.
Outside Tuesday’s council critics circle session, a former council member said the proposed city hall design looks too much like a 1950s-era Modernist intrusion into a 19th century setting. “There’s a reason (the city) bought and bulldozed Ray’s Place,” the critic said, referring to a former bait shop, beer joint and catfish restaurant which once occupied part of the convention center site.
Another critic said, outside the meeting, that the civic center design is reminiscent of any number of recent metal-sheathed steel buildings erected to house Protestant mega-church congregations.
Without getting insistent, Fatter also reminded the council that both building projects face significant cost constraints. The convention center structure as presently planned will cover some 26,000 square feet. The city hall plan includes up to 15,000 square feet. Total costs for both, including planned improvements to Chestnut St., could approach $10 million.
Fatter is not new to Bastrop’s building history. He designed the city’s Adell Powell Police and Court Building in the late 1990s.